Cross-checks between SEO and ads
Cross-checks between SEO and ads are proposals that come from looking at your website and your Google Ads campaigns together, over the same query bank: which query no longer needs paying for, which deserves an article, which is expensive for an ad and which new page is worth covering with ads while it climbs. They are in the SEO / ads cross-checks section, in Marketing → Search visibility, Keywords tab, and in Marketing → Search opportunities.
What is it for?
SEO and ads (SEM) work with the same queries, but each one only sees its own. The ERP sees both and warns you when one can help the other:
- Don’t pay for what you already have. If your website already appears among the top results in Google for a query, part of what you pay in ads for it is clicks you already had.
- Write about what buys. What people searched for when they clicked your ad and ended in a conversion is demand that buys: it deserves a page on your website.
- Don’t pay for people who only want to learn. An informational query (‘what is…’, ‘how to…’) with an expensive click works better as an article than as an ad.
- Cover what is new while it climbs. A new page takes time to reach the top in Google; in the meantime, an ad brings in the visits.
They are proposals: nothing changes until you accept them.
What cross-checks does it propose?
| Cross-check | When it appears | What it proposes |
|---|---|---|
| Already at the top without paying | The query appears in Google’s top 3 organic positions and is also a keyword in a campaign | Lower the bid (to the Keyword Planner’s low bid or, without it, 30 % less) or Pause the keyword |
| Converts in ads | The query has conversions in your ads’ search terms report and no page or piece of yours targets it | Create the piece in the editorial plan, with that query as main and in its cluster if it has one |
| A page of yours has it, but below position 10 (or Google doesn’t show it yet) | Raise the priority: a ×1,5 priority guideline for that query | |
| Expensive informational | Informational query whose click (the Keyword Planner’s high bid) costs half or more of your maximum CPC, or 1,50 € or more | Create the piece and mark it negative in the ads; if it already has an owner, only Mark it negative; if it is already negative, only Create the piece |
| Piece not ranking yet | A piece from the editorial plan published 30 days ago or more whose main query still isn’t in the top 10 | Choose it for the ads: on Send to the campaign it will go to its topic’s ad group. When it reaches the top, the first cross-check will propose withdrawing it |
The numbers in the table are the defaults: they are changed in Guidelines → SEO weights and thresholds, SEO / ads cross-checks group.
Each proposal states its reason with the data behind it (‘It ranks in position 2 on Google without paying and is also a keyword in Search › Invoicing…’) and, on each button, what it will do (‘from 1,20 € to 0,45 €’).
What happens with the channel guideline?
It always wins. What marketing wants for ads only doesn’t get proposals that take it to SEO (lowering its bid, creating a piece for it, raising its priority or making it negative). What it wants for SEO only doesn’t get the one to cover it with ads. What is vetoed gets none. See the marketing guidelines.
Where is each one accepted?
Each screen shows its own:
- In Opportunities (Google Ads), those that change the ads: lowering the bid or pausing, choosing for the ads and the expensive informational one.
- In Keywords (Search visibility), those that change the SEO plan: creating the piece, raising the priority and the expensive informational one.
With the All filter you also see those from the other screen, with a note saying where they are accepted.
What does accepting one do?
The same as you would do by hand, with your name behind it:
- Lower the bid sets the bid of each keyword for that query in the campaigns; Pause the keyword leaves it out (it stops being exported). The campaigns are then exported as usual.
- Create the piece adds it to the editorial plan as an idea, with the query as main; its conflicts are checked like those of any piece.
- Raise the priority creates the guideline in Guidelines; it is removed from there.
- Mark it negative and Choose it for the ads decide the query in Opportunities, as if you had decided it there: no rule changes it again. They go into the campaign on Send to the campaign.
After accepting, the section says what has changed in the scores (‘Google Ads: 1 query goes up’).
Create the piece and mark it negative touches both things: first the piece is created and then the negative is marked. If the second couldn’t be done, the piece stays and the section says so: accept the proposal again, which will now only mark the negative (the piece isn’t repeated).
And if I don’t want it?
Click Discard. It doesn’t appear again unless the data that led to it change: if the bid goes up, more conversions arrive, the query changes owner or the page changes position, it is proposed again. The same with an accepted one that would keep appearing (a bid already lowered that could still be lowered further): it stays as dealt with. At the bottom, the section counts how many are dismissed or dealt with.
Can I ask the assistant to do it?
Yes. ‘Which queries that already rank at the top in Google are we still paying for in the ads’, ‘which ad terms that convert have no article on the website’ or ‘which informational queries are too expensive to advertise’ read the proposals with their reason. Accepting or dismissing them is done on screen.
What permissions are needed?
To see them, being able to open the screen is enough: View on Search visibility in Keywords, or on Marketing in Opportunities. To accept, what counts is the permission for what each action changes, whichever screen it is accepted from:
| Action | You need Changes on |
|---|---|
| Lower the bid, Pause the keyword, Mark it negative, Choose it for the ads | Marketing (they change the ads) |
| Create the piece | Search visibility (it changes the editorial plan) |
| Create the piece and mark it negative | Both |
| Raise the priority (it is a marketing guideline) | Either of the two |
| Discard | Either of the two |
An action you lack the permission for is greyed out, and hovering over it says which one you are missing.
What is needed for cross-checks to appear?
- Both modules are needed: the Google Ads dashboard (with its query bank) and Search visibility. Without one of the two, the section says why there are no cross-checks.
- The organic position comes from Search Console (the reading in Opportunities or that of your website in Search visibility): without any Search Console data, the first and last cross-checks don’t appear.
- The bid that the cross-check lowers is left set by hand: Send to the campaign again updates the Keyword Planner data for that keyword, but doesn’t change its bid (and warns you). To go back to the rule’s bid, change it in the campaign.
Back to search visibility.
More about Search positioning
- Guest posts
- Proposed clusters
- Connect your website with Google: Search Console and Analytics
- Query real search data: what it costs
- Add your website and test the connection
- Search data: volume, difficulty and Google results
- Marketing guidelines: what marketing tells the plan
- The editorial calendar
- A piece’s brief
- The content map: what each page of your website targets
- The Looker Studio dashboard: your content map alongside what Google measures
- The editorial plan